|
Post by Sunnypaw on Apr 13, 2023 16:47:48 GMT
I suspect that Spidershade murderer was Foxclaw. Here is why I think that: -In the Gathering, when you ask a cat (I'm sorry, I can't remember who it was) it tells you something about Thornstep and how did she secretly met sometimes with Spidershade. It also tells you that Foxclaw hated Spidershade because Thornstep's kits looked suspiciously like Spidershade. And when Ravenwing shouts that Spidershade is dead Foxclaw isn't in the camp so... I also think that Thrushfeather is suspicious too, because when you have finished the hunting training she tells you that she has to do something and later Ravenwing founds Spidershade dead. Maybe Thrushfeather hated Spidershade because he had kits with Thornstep. Probably Thronstep died giving birth or because pregnancy complications. (I apologize if there is any spelling mistake. English is not my first language)
|
|
|
Post by Sunnypaw on Apr 13, 2023 16:50:17 GMT
I suspect that Spidershade murderer was Foxclaw. Here is why I think that: -In the Gathering, when you ask a cat (I'm sorry, I can't remember who it was) it tells you something about Thornstep and how did she secretly met sometimes with Spidershade. It also tells you that Foxclaw hated Spidershade because Thornstep's kits looked suspiciously like Spidershade. And when Ravenwing shouts that Spidershade is dead Foxclaw isn't in the camp so... I also think that Thrushfeather is suspicious too, because when you have finished the hunting training she tells you that she has to do something. (I apologize if there is any spelling mistake. English is not my first language)
|
|
|
Post by Flamewing on Jan 4, 2024 22:54:29 GMT
I suspect that Spidershade murderer was Foxclaw. Here is why I think that: -In the Gathering, when you ask a cat (I'm sorry, I can't remember who it was) it tells you something about Thornstep and how did she secretly met sometimes with Spidershade. It also tells you that Foxclaw hated Spidershade because Thornstep's kits looked suspiciously like Spidershade. And when Ravenwing shouts that Spidershade is dead Foxclaw isn't in the camp so... I also think that Thrushfeather is suspicious too, because when you have finished the hunting training she tells you that she has to do something and later Ravenwing founds Spidershade dead. Maybe Thrushfeather hated Spidershade because he had kits with Thornstep. Probably Thronstep died giving birth or because pregnancy complications. (I apologize if there is any spelling mistake. English is not my first language) Are you really going to trust the words of the same cat who tells that no one in ShadowClan remembers Spidershade's murder and is acting as ShadowClan spy ? I don't think it's Foxclaw. While he doesn't want to talk about Thornstep if you ask him at the gathering, none of your Clanmates want to as it seems something horrible had happened to her (the reactions when your name is Thornpaw, Mosstail's words when you ask him about it, etc). As for the other suspects I see here: Amberflame: having friends in other clans doesn't mean she will kill someone for her Clan's benefit, she's not a Hawk. Trushfeather: I must say, she is suspicious. While she might like less if you ask her about it because she doesn't think it's your business, after Oakstar leaves, she say that what matters is that no ThunderClan cat murdered Spidershade as if she doesn't want others to investigate. Nettleclaw: No. While she can be aggressive, if you patrol with her and Duskpaw, she'll say that she doesn't want to be a clawmaster just to beat everyone and she doesn't seem that into the Hawks. Blackheart: While he has knowledge about cat anatomy (he can teach it to you) and probably knows about Spidershade's weakness, him killing him over some herbs is unlikely, if he really needed them he could have asked Pebbleskip. Besides, he is the one who challenges death don't the one that causes it. It will be completely opposite to his character. Ravenwing: I don't think it's her. I see her finding the body as a sort of tribute to Ravenpaw who was the one announce Redtail's death. I think she wanted to appologize to Pebbleskip because she is friend with him and she is sorry for him as he was problably good friends with Spidershade (we saw that because of his health issues, Kestrelpaw and Blackheart became good friends so it might be the same for Pebbleskip and Spidershade.) So Thrushfeather remains the most suspicious here.
|
|
|
Post by Crystalizedmire on Apr 28, 2024 17:40:49 GMT
If we're really considering apprentices as murder suspects then Duskpaw is probably the most likely personality-wise since he is the most reckless plus (if it is to be believed) the two truths and a lie answers reveal that Duskpaw is the evil one out of the apprentices. If we are only considering warriors, Waspwing seems like a good bet since the only time we saw him that day was that he was in camp and showing up to fight the fight the fox which either means that he was in camp for the whole day or he sneaked out at some point. If Waspwing is indeed the murderer, then it would probably be taking back the clearing
|
|